One Man & His Blog

User Generated Pointlessness

Nokia Advert

I know the whole idea of “user generated content” is vastly divisive. Some people see it as a great idea, some as a patronising view of people in general and others as an embarrassing attempt by brands to cash in on new Web 2.0 technologies.But some examples strike me as completely pointless. Take this example (in the image) that I stumbled across while doing some phone research for my sister-in-law. Apparently Nokia are offering me the chance to use some videos (isn’t “our” and “user-generated” a contradiction in terms?) to make…our own advert.

Which begs the question: “why?”. What possible user benefit is there in doing this? This just reeks of someone in marketing saying “that YouTube is cool, let’s do something like that”. It makes me cringe, just looking at it.

No, I didn’t click through to find out more. It just didn’t seem worth it.

Written by

Adam Tinworth   Adam Tinworth

Adam has been a blogger for over 20 years, and a journalist for more than 25. He currently works as a consultant and trainer, helping people do better, more engaged online journalism.


Sign up or Sign in to join the conversation.